4 Johnnycake Hill Rd, Old Lyme — property record card
Single Fam built in 1887, 5 bed, 3.5 bath, 3,952 ft² in Old Lyme, appraised at $1,324,600 (assessed $934,700); last sold for $1,425,000 on August 26, 2025.
Rebuilt from the public Connecticut CAMA and Parcel Layer — not the official card. For the official card, with owner, photo and sketch, ask the Old Lyme assessor’s office.
Parcel
| Location | 4 Johnnycake Hill Rd, Old Lyme CT 06371 |
|---|
| Parcel ID | 54-2 |
|---|
| CAMA account | 57040-54-2 |
|---|
| Use | Single Fam (state use code 1010) |
|---|
| Zone | RU40 |
|---|
| Planning region | Lower Connecticut River Valley |
|---|
Valuation — revaluation 2024
| Appraised (market value) | $1,324,600
land $461,500 · building $788,400 · outbuildings $74,700 |
|---|
| Assessed (70%) | $934,700
land $323,000 |
|---|
Land
| Lot size | 1.00 acres (43,560 ft²) |
|---|
Building
| Year built | 1887 (effective 2009) |
|---|
| Living area | 3,952 ft² |
|---|
| Rooms | 10 |
|---|
| Bedrooms | 5 |
|---|
| Bathrooms | 3 full, 1 half |
|---|
| Condition | very good |
|---|
Sales
| Last sale | $1,425,000 — August 26, 2025 |
|---|
What this means
- Connecticut taxes property at 70% of its appraised market value: the assessment $934,700 times the town mill rate gives the yearly tax.
- Old Lyme last revalued in 2024. Towns revalue every five years; between two revaluations the appraisal stays the same even if the market moves.
- Assessed 131% above the median for this use in Old Lyme ($404,200, 4,150 parcels).
- The last sale price is 8% above the appraisal.
- Built before 1978: lead paint may be present; Connecticut law requires disclosure to a buyer or tenant.
Point at the centre of the parcel — not a survey.
Data: Connecticut CAMA and Parcel Layer (2026 collection, CC0), retrieved October 31, 2026. Sources and freshness. No owner names are published.
The report for 4 Johnnycake Hill Rd
This card shows what the assessor records. The report adds what lies around the parcel: FEMA flood zone, wetlands and watercourses, aquifer protection area, Natural Diversity Database areas, brownfields nearby and sewer service.
$19card · PDF within 24 h · you pay after receiving itSee the sample (PDF)
Order the report